Time Best Spent On Other Things

Tuesday, November 15, 2005

'In Gods We Trust' argues against group selection due to the volatility of ideas ie low fidelity in transmission and mutability upon reciept. Reference to an inference model of idea transmission - members of an evangelical church unable to define any given commandment either consistantly, or in such a way that other memebers can reconstruct the commandment from the definition.

Textual trnasmission and organizational momentum / inertia may mitigate this somewhat.

Regardless, unlike an organism where the genotype+environment results in a given phenotype. In social/political structures, any phenotype that can be observed is merely the external manifestation of an equilibrium of its constituent members.

Textual/ritual 'genotypes' can reinforce or mitigate against these constituent forces, but they are ultimately manipulated by them.